These are Indiana’s Best Pizza Joints According To Barstool Sports’ Dave Portnoy

Indiana is home to several great pizza joints, some of which have been featured on Barstool Sports' web series,  called "One Bite," but which ones are the highest rated?

National Pizza Day is coming up on February 9th, so in honor of that, I thought it would be fun to talk about some of the best pizzas throughout Indiana. What better way to do that than by Dave Portnoy's reviews of Indiana pizza joints from "One Bite?"

"One bite. Everyone knows the rules."

For those who don't know, Dave Portnoy, founder of Barstool Sports, once told a friend of his, years ago, that he could eat pizza every day. Just to back up what he said, he began doing just that. He ate pizza every day and posted video reviews about each one. His shtick is to only take one bite and give his honest opinion about the pizza, followed by a numbered rating. As the years went by, this video review show got bigger and bigger. It has blossomed into a show called One Bite with Davey Pageviews, he's even got an accompanying app, and most recently his own line of frozen pizzas that are actually really good.

So, Dave travels a lot for work, and when he is out he tries out as many local pizza shops in the area as possible. He has been all over the country doing this for years, including right here in Indiana. Whether he is in the state for a football game, racing event, or whatever, he always tries out a new local pizza joint and gives a review. But which Indiana pizzas were the best reviewed? Let's find out!

Get our free mobile app

Indiana's Best Pizza Joints According To Barstool Sports' Dave Portnoy

So, Dave has visited several pizza joints in Indiana throughout the years. Most of these reviews have come from Indianapolis and Bloomington. However, we have a lot of great places here in the Evansville area that he should definitely try out if he decides to come around here. If you're like me and love a good locally-owned pizza, you might want to give these places a try, based on Dave's recommendations the next time you are in these areas.

According to One Bite Pizza Rankings, these are all of the Indiana pizza joints that Dave Portnoy has visited thus far, along with how he ranked them, and where they rank on a national level out of 1041 pizza joints he has visited across the country. That being said, I did find a couple of Indiana pizza joints that Dave shot a video for that weren't on the list, so those will not have national rankings.

Rico's Pizza in Gary

• One Bite Ranking: 3.2
• National Ranking One Bite Ranking: 993

Napolese Pizzeria in Indianapolis

• One Bite Ranking: 4.1
• National One Bite Ranking: 971

Bazebaux Pizza in Indianapolis

• One Bite Ranking: 5.1
• National One Bite Ranking: 929

Noble Roman's Craft Pizza & Pub in Westfield

• One Bite Ranking: 5.9
• National One Bite Ranking: 873

Mother Bear's Pizza Campus in Bloomington

• One Bite Ranking: 6.1
• National One Bite Ranking: 847

Eric Gordon's Greek's Pizzeria in Bloomington

• One Bite Ranking: 6.4
• National One Bite Ranking: 784

Strong's Brick Oven Pizzeria in Lawrenceburg

• One Bite Ranking: 6.7
• National One Bite Ranking: 705

Pasquale's Pizza & Pasta in Indianapolis

• One Bite Ranking: 6.7
• National One Bite Ranking: 705

Rockit's Famous Pizza in Bloomington

• One Bite Ranking: 6.9
• National One Bite Ranking: N/A

Bryne's Grilled Pizza in Indianapolis

• One Bite Ranking: 7.1
• National One Bite Ranking: 535

Butch's in Bloomington

• One Bite Ranking: 7.2
• National One Bite Ranking: N/A

Giorgio's Pizza in Indianapolis

• One Bite Ranking: 7.4
• National One Bite Ranking: 357

Brozinni Pizzeria at Speedway in Speedway

• One Bite Ranking: 7.4
• National One Bite Ranking: 357

Goodfellas Pizzeria in Indianapolis

• One Bite Ranking: 8.1
• National One Bite Ranking: 105